INSIGHTS · Interview

You’re Giving All the Right Interview Answers. So Why Aren’t You Getting Hired?

Why the perfect interview answer isn't always the best one — and what recruiters actually want to hear.

You’ve researched the company. You’ve practiced your elevator pitch. You’ve Googled the most common interview questions, watched videos about how to answer them, and maybe even asked ChatGPT to help you come up with the perfect responses.

You’re ready for anything. Or are you?

After 21 years in recruiting, I’ve interviewed more candidates than I can count. And one of the things I’ve noticed is that some candidates are so focused on delivering the right answer that they forget to do something incredibly important.

Actually listen to the question.

It sounds simple, doesn’t it? But you’d be surprised how often it happens.  And sometimes, the candidates who have prepared the most are the ones who struggle with it.

You’re Answering the Question You Prepared For, Not the One I Asked

One of my biggest frustrations as a recruiter is when I ask a candidate a question and they answer something entirely different. Not because they misunderstood a word or needed a moment to collect their thoughts. That happens, and I completely understand.

I’m talking about candidates who are so focused on what they want to say that they aren’t really listening to what I’m asking. For example, one of the behavioral-based interview questions I frequently ask is:

“Tell me about a time when you were in a stressful situation. What happened, and how did you handle it?”

You might be surprised how often I hear something along the lines of:

“Oh, I handle stress really well. I don’t let things get to me. I’m good under pressure.”

Okay. But that’s not what I asked. I didn’t ask whether you handle stress well. I asked you to tell me about a specific time when you experienced stress and what you did about it.

There’s a big difference. And here’s something else I want job seekers to understand: It’s okay to admit that you experience stress.

Everyone does. Period.

It’s unrealistic to suggest that you’ve never felt stressed at work. And when someone tells me that nothing ever stresses them out, I’m not necessarily impressed.

I want to understand what kind of stressful situation you’ve encountered, how you responded, and what you did to manage it. Maybe you were juggling multiple competing deadlines. Maybe you had to deal with an upset customer.  Maybe something went wrong on a project and you had to figure out how to fix it.

Those are the examples I’m interested in hearing.

When I ask, “Tell me about a time when you were in a stressful situation and what you did,” I’m not asking candidates to convince me that stress doesn’t affect them. I’m trying to understand how they respond when it does.

But candidates sometimes become so concerned about saying something that might reflect negatively on them that they end up giving a generic, overly polished answer instead of a meaningful one. And that can work against them.

When You Don’t Answer the Question, Here’s What I’m Thinking

I want to share something that happens on the other side of the interview.

When I ask a question and the candidate doesn’t answer it, a few things go through my mind. Are they nervous? Are they not listening? Or do they simply not have an example to share?

I don’t automatically assume the worst. I know interviews can be intimidating, especially in the first few minutes. In fact, I’ll often redirect the conversation and give the candidate another opportunity.

I might say something like:

“Thank you for sharing that. What I’m really looking for is a specific example of a time when you experienced that situation. Can you tell me about one?”

I’m trying to help them give me the information I need. But if we’re halfway through the interview and I’m still having to repeatedly redirect someone back to the question, it starts to affect my impression. And here’s why.

An interview isn’t just about whether you have the technical qualifications for the job. It’s also an opportunity to demonstrate how you listen, communicate, and interact with other people.

If you’re consistently answering questions that weren’t asked, you’re not necessarily demonstrating those skills very well.

An Interview Is a Conversation, Not a Research Paper

Let me be clear about something. I’m a big believer in interview preparation.

Research the company. Learn about the position. Practice answering questions. Use Google, social media, AI, or whatever resources help you feel more confident. There’s absolutely nothing wrong with that.

But there’s a difference between preparing for an interview and preparing a performance.

I recently interviewed someone who appeared to be reading her responses directly from a script. And I could tell. The answers didn’t sound natural. They sounded like something that had been written out and rehearsed rather than someone genuinely speaking to me.

Here’s the thing. A job interview isn’t a research paper. It’s a conversation.

You’re talking to another person. You need to be able to listen, think, respond, and engage in a genuine exchange. And when you’re reading a carefully prepared script, you’re not really doing that.

I actually encourage candidates to have notes in front of them during interviews, especially virtual interviews.

Write down a few talking points. Have some examples of accomplishments you want to mention. Keep a list of questions you’d like to ask. That’s perfectly fine.

But don’t write out paragraphs and read them word-for-word. Not only does it sound unnatural, but it can also make it harder to adapt when the interviewer asks something you weren’t expecting.

And trust me, we’re not all going to start with “Tell me about yourself.” If you’ve spent hours perfecting your elevator pitch and the interviewer opens with a completely different question, you need to be able to adjust.

Prepare your thoughts. Don’t memorize your personality.

So, How Should You Actually Prepare? When I’m coaching someone who has an important interview, here’s where I tell them to focus their energy:

First, understand the job you’re interviewing for. You should be able to explain, in your own words, what the position involves. Not recite the job description. Not repeat the company’s website verbatim. Actually explain what you understand the job to be. If you can’t do that, you probably need to spend more time preparing.

Second, know why you want the job. Why this company? Why this department? Why this particular position? And please, go beyond telling me that the company has a great reputation or that you’re looking for an opportunity to grow. Those things might be true, but what specifically interests you? What about the work appeals to you? How does it align with your experience, interests, or career goals? You should be able to communicate that naturally and convincingly.

Third, have examples of your accomplishments ready. Think about things you’ve achieved in your career, particularly your more recent experiences. What are you proud of? What problems have you solved? What challenges have you overcome? What have you contributed to your team or organization?

You don’t need to memorize a script for each example. You just need to know your own experiences well enough to talk about them.

Fourth, anticipate the competencies the interviewer will want to explore. If you’re an experienced professional interviewing for a similar role, you probably already have a pretty good understanding of the skills and qualifications needed to succeed. Think about what those are.

If communication, teamwork, problem-solving, or managing competing priorities are important parts of the job, be prepared to discuss situations where you’ve demonstrated those abilities. You may not know the exact questions you’ll be asked, but you can prepare relevant examples.

And yes, I absolutely recommend practicing. Practice speaking out loud. Practice in front of a mirror. Pay attention to your facial expressions, body language, and how you’re communicating. Just don’t confuse practicing with memorizing.

It’s Okay to Stop and Think

Here’s something I wish more candidates understood. You do not have to answer every interview question immediately.

If I ask you something and you need a few seconds to think, take them.

You can even say:

“That’s a great question. Let me think about that for a second.”

That’s perfectly acceptable. I’ve even had candidates ask if they could come back to a question later in the interview. And that’s okay, too.

I’d much rather have someone take a moment and provide a thoughtful, relevant answer than immediately launch into a rehearsed response that doesn’t address what I asked. Take your time. Listen to the question. Think about what the interviewer is actually trying to learn. Then answer it.

Don’t Underestimate the Power of Genuine Enthusiasm

There’s something else I want to talk about that doesn’t get nearly enough attention in interview preparation.

Enthusiasm.

I have interviewed so many candidates who seem lukewarm about the opportunity they’re interviewing for.

They’re qualified. They answer the questions. They might even have an impressive résumé. But I walk away wondering whether they actually want the job. And that’s not the impression you want to leave.

Qualifications matter, of course. There are certain skills, credentials, and experiences that employers need.

But many hard skills can be taught. Genuine enthusiasm, positive attitude, and an authentic interest in the work are much harder to teach.

You don’t have to be the loudest or most outgoing person in the room to demonstrate enthusiasm. You can show it by being engaged in the conversation, asking thoughtful questions, explaining why the role interests you, and communicating how you believe you could contribute.

And here’s a little piece of advice. If you want the job, say so. At the end of the interview, there’s absolutely nothing wrong with saying:

“I just want to let you know that I’m very interested in this opportunity. After learning more about the position, I think my experience would be a great fit, and I’d be excited to contribute to the team.”

You might assume the interviewer already knows you’re interested because you applied and showed up. Don’t assume that. There’s something to be said for simply expressing genuine interest.

And if you’re interviewing for positions that you have absolutely no enthusiasm for, I’d encourage you to think about why you’re pursuing them in the first place. I understand that sometimes people need a job, and they don’t always have the luxury of waiting for the perfect opportunity. But when you can identify what genuinely interests you about a position, it makes a difference in how you communicate during the interview.

You Can’t Say the Wrong Thing to the Right Person

I want to leave you with something I genuinely believe. And it might sound a little cliché, but I think it applies to job interviews just as much as I used to apply it to the dating scene.

You can’t say the wrong thing to the right person. Period.  Now, that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t prepare, communicate professionally, or put your best foot forward. Of course you should.

But I don’t believe you get to the right opportunity by pretending to be someone you’re not. If you have to memorize the perfect answers, suppress your personality, and tell an interviewer everything you think they want to hear just to get hired, is that really the best way to find the right fit? I don’t think so.

The right employer should recognize the value you bring because you’ve been able to communicate your experience, strengths, and genuine interest in the opportunity. Not because you delivered a flawless script.

So prepare for your interview. Do your research. Know your accomplishments. Practice talking about your experience. But when the interview begins, put the script aside.

Listen. Have a conversation. Be yourself. And trust that the right opportunity will recognize what you have to offer.

And if you’d like some additional practice or feedback on your interviewing skills, I’m happy to help.

Share

More from the Recruiting Desk

Behind the Recruiting Desk

Practical career advice, recruiter insights, and strategies to help you navigate your job search and career with confidence.

Career advice and recruiter insights delivered to your inbox. Unsubscribe anytime.